Thursday, June 12, 2014

WinSCP vs Samba For Windows <---> Ubuntu Development

I've always used WinSCP to transfer files between my Windows development environment and Ubuntu. It worked pretty well. All you had to do was open the file with your editor by clicking the file in WinSCP, and when you saved the file it would save to the server in the background.

The main negative was the lack of feedback when a file fails to save to the server. WinSCP could be logged out and asking for a password in the background, but you were expecting that save to fix the bug you were working on. It ended up being another thing to debug.

A coworker suggested using Samba instead. I installed it with this simple guide: How to Create a Network Share Via Samba Via CLI Then I mapped the network drive in Windows by going to the "Map Network Drive" option in the tools menu of the file explorer:

The only negative I've found with Samba so far is that it makes Notepad++ a little less responsive. But it helps a small amount if you turn off "File Status Auto-Detection":

2 comments:

  1. So other than the ability to monitor file transfer progress and cater for authentication what advantage has Samba over WinSCP? I've not encountered any issue so far with file transfer using WinSCP. Just want to know.

    ReplyDelete
  2. So other than the ability to monitor file transfer progress and cater for authentication what advantage has Samba over WinSCP? I've not encountered any issue so far with file transfer using WinSCP. Just want to know.

    ReplyDelete